Canadians tend to use “nonprofit” and “charity” as if they mean the same thing. Under the Income Tax Act they are two different animals, and the gap usually surfaces at an awkward moment, like when a donor asks for a tax receipt the organization has no legal right to issue.
Table of Contents
What a Nonprofit Actually Is
A nonprofit is any club, society or association that exists for a purpose other than making money for its members. Minor hockey leagues, professional associations and residents’ groups all fit here. Most incorporate, federally under the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act or provincially under statutes like Ontario’s Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, though they don’t have to.
A nonprofit generally doesn’t pay income tax on what it earns, and that is where the tax advantage ends. It cannot issue official donation receipts, so if someone hands it $500, that person gets a thank-you card and nothing to claim at tax time.
What Makes a Registered Charity Different
A registered charity has applied to the Canada Revenue Agency’s Charities Directorate, shown that its purposes fall within the legal definition of charity (relieving poverty, advancing education, advancing religion, or another purpose the courts have recognized as benefiting the community), and been issued a registration number.
That number is what unlocks the receipt. Donors get a federal and provincial tax credit, and foundations, corporate giving programs and many government funders will only deal with organizations that hold one. For a group that plans to live on donations, this is the whole ballgame.
The trade-off is oversight. A registered charity files a T3010 information return every year, and that filing is public. It has to spend a minimum amount on charitable work each year, faces limits on business activity, and cannot support a political party or candidate. Fall far enough behind on the filing and the CRA can revoke the registration, receipts and all.
How to Decide Between the Two
Practitioners in this area, including the Toronto team at B.I.G. Charity Law Group, tend to open with a single question: will you need to hand out donation receipts? If the honest answer is yes, or if grant applications to foundations are part of the plan, a nonprofit will feel like a placeholder within a year.
If the answer is no, because members pay dues or you sell tickets, or because your purpose (an advocacy campaign, say, or a recreational league) wouldn’t qualify as charitable anyway, the nonprofit is the cleaner choice. It is faster to set up and much cheaper to run.
The two paths also overlap. In Canada, a registered charity is almost always a nonprofit corporation that went on to register with the CRA. Plenty of organizations incorporate first and apply for charitable status a year or two later, once the mission and the funding settle. Before going that route it helps to understand what registering a charity in Canada involves, because the CRA application is where the months go. Purposes have to be drafted carefully and activities described in enough detail for a reviewer to connect the two, and vague wording at this stage is one of the more common reasons an application stalls.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a nonprofit become a registered charity later?
Yes, provided its purposes are exclusively charitable. The articles often need amending first, since a purpose clause written for a general nonprofit rarely satisfies the Charities Directorate as drafted.
Do Canadian nonprofits pay income tax?
Generally no, as long as they operate only for non-profit purposes and don’t distribute income to members. Some nonprofits still have to file an annual information return (Form T1044) once their investment income or total assets pass certain thresholds.
How long does charity registration take?
The CRA’s service standard for a complete regular application is six months, and the Charities Directorate has reported average times to a final decision of around five months. Anything that draws a round of questions from the reviewer takes longer.
